9 Best Artificial Fireplace Inserts | Stop Chimney Drafts Cold

Our readers keep the lights on and my morning glass full of iced black tea. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.

You can get the glow and warmth of a fireplace without ever touching a single log, sweeping a speck of ash, or opening a drafty damper. Artificial fireplace inserts plug into a standard wall outlet and deliver the whole package: realistic flame effects plus supplemental heat. The trick is matching the right insert to the size of your room and how important the flame look is to you.

I’m Min — the founder and writer behind Gadgets Feed. This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.

The question is which insert delivers the most realistic flame effect and the most useful supplemental heat for the size of your space. That is exactly what this guide to the best artificial fireplace inserts is for — cutting through the clutter so you can find the one that fits your home.

Our Picks at a Glance

RICHFLAME 33 Inches, Edward Electric Fireplace Insert
Best OverallRICHFLAME 33 Inches, Edward Electric Fireplace Insert4.8★545 ratingsThe insert that fools your guests into thinking you installed a real masonry fireplace. This is the crowd favorite for good reason.Check Price on Amazon
Kentsky 30 inches Electric Fireplace Insert
Most Versatile ColorsKentsky 30 inches Electric Fireplace Insert4.4★515 ratingsA color-changing canvas that lets you switch from cozy amber to cool blue with a tap. If you want a fireplace that matches your decor instead of dictating it, this 30-inch Kentsky is the one.Check Price on Amazon
COSTWAY Electric Fireplace Insert 28.5-inch
Best ValueCOSTWAY Electric Fireplace Insert 28.5-inch4.5★729 ratingsA budget-friendly heater that punches above its price in warmth and reliability. The COSTWAY 28.5-inch insert is the choice when you care more about heating performance than having 144 color combinations.Check Price on Amazon

How To Choose The Best Artificial Fireplace Inserts

An artificial fireplace insert is basically a self-contained electric heater with a light show. But the specs that separate a good one from a disappointing one are specific and easy to check once you know what they mean.

Heating Power and Coverage

Most inserts run on a standard 120V household outlet and offer two heat settings: 750W and 1500W. The 750W setting is for mild-chill days or smaller rooms; the 1500W setting pushes out roughly 5,000 BTUs (BTU stands for British Thermal Unit, a measure of heat energy), which is enough to warm a space up to 400 square feet as a supplemental heater — not a primary furnace replacement. If your room is bigger than that, look for units with infrared heating elements or those rated for 1,000 square feet.

Flame Realism and Customization

The whole point of an artificial insert is that it looks like a real fire. The best inserts use layered LED projections and reflective ember beds to create depth — a flat, screen-like flame is the giveaway of a cheap unit. Many now offer multiple flame colors (from classic orange to blue or purple), adjustable brightness levels, and separate control over the ember bed color so you can dial in the exact mood.

Fit and Installation

Measure your existing fireplace opening — width, height, and depth — before you buy anything. Inserts designed for old wood or gas fireplaces have a boxy shape meant to slide in and be surrounded by a trim kit. Wall-mounted and recessed units are thinner (around 4-6 inches deep) and meant to be framed into a wall. Getting the dimensions right is the single most common buyer mistake.

Quick Comparison

Model Best For Heat Output (BTU) Coverage (sq. ft) Flame Colors Amazon
RICHFLAME 33″★ Best Overall Realism & Heat 5,000 400 3 settings Amazon
Kentsky 30″Most Versatile Colors Color Variety — 400 13 flame / 13 bed Amazon
COSTWAY 28.5″Best Value Budget Value — 400 3 Amazon
EUHOMY 60″ Wide Linear Style — 400 12 flame / 12 bed Amazon
RealSmart 60″ Ultra-Slim Profile 1,500W — 12 flame / 12 bed Amazon
Kentsky 28″ Vintage Look — 400 3 Amazon
LegendFlame Carl 28″ Authentic Sound & Look 5,000 400 4 brightness Amazon
Signature Design by Ashley 31″ Large Room Heating 5,386 1,000 5 brightness Amazon
Westinghouse 60″ Smart Home Control 5,110 — 144 combos Amazon

In‑Depth Reviews

★ Best Overall

1. RICHFLAME 33 Inches, Edward Electric Fireplace Insert

Our pick — over 4.5★ from 500+ verified ratings; the strongest balance of quality and price.

Weathered Concrete InteriorFire Crackling Sound

The insert that fools your guests into thinking you installed a real masonry fireplace.

This is the crowd favorite for good reason. The weathered concrete interior does the heavy lifting — it gives the firebox a depth that flat black interiors cannot match. The flame effect has three settings, and when you add the crackling sound (you can turn it off if the speaker quality bugs you), the combination feels genuinely warm and alive, not like a video screen. One buyer says “this fit as an insert to replace our wood burning fireplace” and calls the overall look “clean.”

On the heating side, the 5,000 BTU (British Thermal Unit) quartz element warms up to 400 square feet. The two heat settings (750W and 1500W) let you save energy on milder days. At 55.8 pounds and 35 inches wide, this is a substantial unit — it is 8.8 inches deep, so measure your opening carefully. The CSA (Canadian Standards Association) certification and overheat protection give confidence for continuous use. A few owners find the speaker crackling sound unconvincing, but the silent mode solves that instantly.

Flame depth impact

  • The weathered concrete interior looks premium and creates realistic depth
  • Puts out real supplemental heat — enough to make a cold, drafty room cozy
  • Simple installation: buyers report it slides into an existing opening with no fuss

Heating coverage limited

  • At 55.8 pounds, it demands two people to lift into place
  • The speaker for the crackling sound is not great — most buyers just turn the sound off

Strong flame visuals: you want the most realistic flame effect in a traditional insert size and value the heated concrete look over a flat black box.

Check room size: you have a very shallow fireplace opening — the 8.8-inch depth is deeper than some wall-mount units.

Most Versatile Colors

2. Kentsky 30 inches Electric Fireplace Insert

13 Flame ColorsTouch Screen Control

A color-changing canvas that lets you switch from cozy amber to cool blue with a tap.

If you want a fireplace that matches your decor instead of dictating it, this 30-inch Kentsky is the one. It offers 13 flame colors and 13 LED (light-emitting diode) fuel bed colors, which means you can create everything from a natural orange burn to a dramatic purple-and-blue show. The touch-screen panel on the unit itself makes color-switching intuitive, and the remote mirrors every function. It also includes realistic logs and crystals so you can style the ember bed to your taste.

The heater runs at 750W or 1500W and covers up to 400 sq. ft., with a smart thermostat that holds a set temperature between 62°F and 99°F. Owners mention the heat output is “pretty standard (about as much as a blow dryer) for plug in models” and that the fan is relatively quiet. One recurring note is that the remote emits a loud beep with every button press, and it requires line-of-sight aiming.

Compact efficiency: If you love customizing the mood of a room through color, this insert gives you more options than anything near its price tier. The beeping remote is a minor annoyance you will notice at first then tune out.

Space-saving heat: anyone who wants a fireplace that can shift from natural flame to party mood lighting at will.

Limited ambiance: you want a silent remote — that audible beep is part of the experience here.

Best Value

3. COSTWAY Electric Fireplace Insert 28.5-inch

ETL Certified3 Flame Colors

A budget-friendly heater that punches above its price in warmth and reliability.

The COSTWAY 28.5-inch insert is the choice when you care more about heating performance than having 144 color combinations. It heats up to 400 square feet with the same 750W/1500W settings as the pricier units, and buyers consistently report that it keeps a master bedroom comfortable overnight. The three flame colors (with five brightness levels each) look decent — not as layered as the RICHFLAME, but realistic enough for the price.

At 27.5 pounds, it is 27.5 pounds compared to the RICHFLAME at 55.8 pounds, which makes recessed installation much easier — one person can handle it. The ETL (a safety certification mark from Intertek) certification and overheat protection are solid safety marks. The thermostat lets you set a range from 62°F to 82°F, and the 8-hour timer is generous. A few customers note the flame effect looks somewhat screen-like versus higher-end models, and the remote control gets mixed feedback for temperature setting responsiveness. But at this price point, the consensus among owners is clear: “Buy it. You will not regret it.”

Cost-effective heat: the practical buyer who wants reliable supplemental heat and a decent-looking flame without spending a premium on ultra-realism.

No smart controls: the flame projection is flatter than more expensive inserts — great for ambiance, not for centerpiece display.

Best Wide Linear

4. EUHOMY 60 Inch Electric Fireplace Recessed

144 Color CombosTempered Glass

Sixty inches of linear flame that turns an entire wall into a focal point.

This is the statement piece. The 60-inch width is built for modern media walls and large living rooms, with a slender depth of just 4.3 inches that makes recessed installation look smooth. The real draw here is the color system: 12 flame colors and 12 ember bed colors combine for 144 total looks, plus an automatic cycling mode that rotates through them in sequence. Reviewers point out it is “beautiful and easy to use” and that the flames look realistic with customizable logs.

The 1,500W heater covers up to 400 square feet, and the thermostat goes up to 82°F. You can run the flame effect without heat year-round. The tempered glass front is sturdy but heavy, and the instruction manual gets some criticism for being unclear. A few owners mention the glass beads (part of the ember bed) are fiddly to keep in place. Still, at 4.7 stars from a large owner base, the EUHOMY is proving itself as a reliable wide-format choice.

Large room heating: homeowners with a wide media console or a built-in wall cavity who want a sleek, modern flame display with massive color flexibility.

Requires recessing: the instructions are not the clearest — expect to spend extra time on installation setup.

Slimmest Profile

5. RealSmart 60″ Electric Fireplace Heater Insert

3.8-Inch Profile12 Color Options

At just 3.8 inches deep, this is the thinnest way to get a built-in fire look.

The RealSmart is engineered for spaces where every inch of depth matters. Its 60-inch width and extremely shallow 3.8-inch profile mean it can slide into a standard 2×6 stud wall with no extra framing. The tempered glass front and 58% screen ratio make the flame display feel oversized for its depth. You get 12 flame colors and 12 ember bed colors, plus five speed levels and five brightness levels, so the customization is generous.

The heater uses a quartz element with a 1,500W output. The thermostat range (65°F to 95°F) is wider than most, and the timer extends to 12 hours. Noise is rated at a whisper-quiet 38 decibels (a measure of sound level). Buyers love the multi-color LED flames and find installation straightforward. However, some report the heater only runs at full blast or off — there is no fine-grained temperature control despite the advertised thermostat — and a few units have arrived without certain accessories like the log set. The weight is listed as 46 kg (over 100 pounds), so this is a very heavy unit despite the slim depth.

Wall-mount sleekness: a custom wall integration where depth is scarce and you want a spectacular, colorful flame canvas.

Durability concerns: the heater control may be on/off rather than true thermostat, and the weight is surprising for such a thin unit — get help moving it.

Vintage Charm

6. Kentsky 28″ Electric Fireplace Insert

Vintage Look9-Hour Timer

A compact insert with a nostalgic brick-lined interior and whisper-quiet operation.

This 28-inch Kentsky leans into a more traditional aesthetic. The overall dimensions (28.7″W x 21.4″H x 6.5″D) and the insert dimensions (25.3″W x 20.1″H x 5.3″D) mean it is designed to drop into a standard masonry opening. It comes completely assembled — one of the easiest installs in this list. Shoppers say it is “near silent” and that the two heat settings warm a room effectively without any disruptive fan noise.

You get three adjustable flame colors and a glowing fuel bed. The 1-9 hour timer is convenient for falling asleep to the glow. The heating coverage covers up to 400 sq. ft., and the unit can run as flame-only ambiance year-round. The look is definitely more vintage than modern — the powder-coated black finish and brick interior fit best in a traditional mantle. No major negatives in the feedback; occasional comments about the mounting system requiring rear access to screws.

Easy setup: you want a simple, no-assembly insert that fits a traditional fireplace and runs almost silently.

Not for large rooms: if you have a mantle that is enclosed on the sides, accessing the mounting screws from the rear can be tricky.

Most Authentic Experience

7. LegendFlame Carl 28″ W Electric Fireplace Insert

Triple Brick InteriorMood Light Settings

The closest you will get to a real fire without chimney cleaning, creosote, or smoke.

The LegendFlame Carl stands out for its interior design: a three-sided brick wall pattern that gives the firebox real depth. The flame projection uses a larger, more random burn pattern with four brightness settings, which avoids the repetitive loop cheap units display. On top of that, nine mood light settings shine down on the resin log to make it look like glowing embers. One buyer describes it as “the best looking large electric insert” and notes that it is “realistic.”

With a 10.39-inch depth, this is the deepest insert here — 2.1 inches deeper than the RICHFLAME — so it needs more room in the fireplace cavity. The 5,000 BTU (British Thermal Unit) heater (750W/1500W) warms up to 400 sq. ft. and comes with an adjustable thermostat. The remote controls the flame, crackling sound, mood lights, and heat. A few owners comment that the heater blows hot air effectively but is not substantial enough to be a primary heat source. The 46-pound weight is manageable for two people.

Traditional look: the buyer who wants the most convincing flame and ember illusion possible in a traditional insert form, including crackling sound and mood light options.

Better flame options: the 10.39-inch depth is the deepest on this list — check your opening depth before ordering.

Large Room Specialist

8. Signature Design by Ashley Electric Infrared Fireplace Insert

Infrared Heating1,000 sq ft Coverage

The infrared heater that actually warms a 1,000-square-foot space, not just the spot in front of it.

Unlike the quartz heaters in most inserts, this Ashley unit uses an infrared heating element (a type of heater that warms objects and people directly, not just the air) that heats objects and people directly rather than just stirring the air. The result is a 5,386 BTU output rated for up to 1,000 square feet — compared to the standard 400 sq. ft. coverage. Buyers confirm it “warms 400-600 sq ft” easily and works as a draft backup in larger rooms. The faux firebrick surround and dynamic glowing embers give it a realistic structure that matches the Ashley brand’s furniture aesthetic.

At 31.25 inches wide and 8.75 inches deep, it is built to fit into compatible Signature Design by Ashley media consoles — a perfect match if you already own that furniture. The remote includes an LED display, seven temperature levels, and a timer from 10 minutes to 9 hours. The five flame brightness settings let you run it as a purely decorative feature in warmer months. One consistent piece of feedback: it is heavy to lift solo, and the glass front shows fingerprints easily.

Trusted brand: large living rooms or open-concept spaces where standard inserts would barely take the chill off — the infrared heat is genuinely different.

Budget alternatives exist: it is designed to pair with Ashley TV stands, so if you are installing in a masonry fireplace, check the fit first.

Smart Home Ready

9. Westinghouse 60 Inch Electric Fireplace Heater

Alexa & Google Compatible144 Color Combos

A voice-controlled, 60-inch masterpiece that speaks both Alexa and Google Home fluently.

The Westinghouse is the most technologically advanced insert in this lineup. Beyond the standard remote, it integrates with Amazon Alexa and Google Home for voice control, plus the Westinghouse app for your phone. That means you can say “Alexa, set the fireplace to 72 degrees” from your couch without fumbling for a remote. The visual side is equally flexible: 12 flame colors and 12 ember bed colors produce 144 total combinations, and the five brightness levels and five flame speeds let you fine-tune the look precisely.

The 60-inch unit fits openings as wide as 59.06 inches and has a shallow 5.5-inch depth, making it viable for wall-mount or recessed installation. The 5,110 BTU (British Thermal Unit) quartz heater includes a thermostat that ranges from 62°F to 82°F. Buyers report it “does a pretty good job of actually heating the room” and that the fan noise is very minimal. The included accessories — a faux log set, camphor wood, and crystals — let you change the ember bed style whenever you want. The main drawbacks are the premium price and the fact that the app only supports one phone at a time.

Rapid warming: the smart-home enthusiast who wants voice control, a huge flame canvas, and the ability to change ember bed materials at will.

Fan noise noticeable: the price is the highest here, and if you share the app with a partner, only one phone can control it at a time.

Understanding the Specs

BTU and Heating Coverage

BTU (British Thermal Unit) measures how much heat the unit can produce. A standard 1,500W electric insert puts out around 5,000 BTUs, which is enough to warm roughly 400 square feet as a supplemental heater — think taking the chill off a living room, not replacing your furnace. Infrared (a type of heat that warms objects and people directly rather than just the air) models can feel warmer because they heat objects directly rather than just the air.

Flame Projection Technology

Not all flames are created equal. Basic inserts use a single LED strip behind a screen, creating a flat, fake look. Better units use multiple LED (light-emitting diode) layers (sometimes called “3D flame projection”) with a reflective ember bed to add depth. The more settings a unit has for flame brightness, speed, and color, the more realistic you can tune it to your actual fireplace opening.

FAQ

Will an artificial fireplace insert fit into my existing wood-burning fireplace?
Most inserts are designed to slide into a standard masonry opening. You need to measure the width, height, and depth of your fireplace cavity and compare it to the insert’s overall dimensions. The RICHFLAME (35″W x 27″H x 8.8″D) and LegendFlame (28.66″W x 21.25″H x 10.39″D) are common traditional insert shapes. Wall-mount units like the Westinghouse and EUHOMY are designed for framing into a wall, not sliding into an existing firebox.
How much does it cost to run an electric fireplace insert per hour?
At the 1,500W setting, an electric insert running on a standard 120V outlet draws about 12.5 amps. The cost depends on your local electricity rate, but it is generally comparable to running a space heater — much less expensive than operating a gas fireplace or burning a full cord of wood. The 750W setting cuts the draw roughly in half.
Can I leave an electric fireplace insert on overnight?
Most quality inserts include overheat protection and a timer. The RICHFLAME has CSA (Canadian Standards Association) certification and an automatic shut-off if it overheats. Many units like the COSTWAY and Kentsky models offer 8-9 hour timers, so you can set them to turn off after you fall asleep. Infrared models like the Signature Design by Ashley tend to run cooler on the exterior, which adds safety for overnight use.
What is the difference between quartz and infrared heating elements?
Quartz heating elements warm the air in the room using a fan to push the heated air outward. They are common in most budget-friendly and mid-range inserts. Infrared (a type of heat that warms objects and people directly) elements heat objects and people directly without relying on a fan, which can feel more comfortable and natural. The Signature Design by Ashley is the infrared model in this lineup, and it covers up to 1,000 square feet compared to the standard 400.
Does the flame effect still look good if I turn the heat off?
Yes — every insert in this list lets you run the flame display independently of the heater. The LED (light-emitting diode) lights consume very little power (often under 30 watts), so you can enjoy the ambiance year-round without adding heat to the room. The EUHOMY and RealSmart units offer the most elaborate color combinations for pure aesthetic use.
How deep does my fireplace need to be for an insert?
Depths vary widely. The deepest insert here is the LegendFlame Carl at 10.39 inches. The RICHFLAME is 8.8 inches deep, while the Kentsky 30-inch is shallower at 5.9 inches. The slimmest are the RealSmart at 3.8 inches and the EUHOMY at 4.3 inches, which fit into walls framed with standard 2×4 or 2×6 studs. Measure your opening depth before buying.
Can I mount a linear fireplace insert on the wall without cutting into it?
Yes — several models support surface wall-mount installation using brackets, including the Kentsky 30-inch, the RealSmart 60-inch, and the Westinghouse. You simply attach the mounting bracket to the wall studs, hang the unit, and plug it into a nearby outlet. Recessed installation (cutting into the wall) creates a flush, built-in appearance and is also an option for most of these.
How loud are the fan and crackling sound on these inserts?
The fan noise on most units is described as quiet — the RealSmart is rated at 38 decibels (whisper-quiet), and the Kentsky 28-inch is noted as “near silent.” The crackling sound quality varies: the RICHFLAME’s speaker is a common complaint, with many owners turning the sound off entirely. The LegendFlame Carl gets better marks for its crackling effect.

Final Thoughts: The Verdict

For the majority of shoppers, the best artificial fireplace inserts winner is the RICHFLAME 33 Inches because it combines a genuinely realistic flame with a weathered concrete interior and reliable 5,000 BTU heat at a balanced price. If you want class-leading color customization and a wide linear display, grab the EUHOMY 60 Inch. And for smart home voice control and the largest coverage area, the Westinghouse 60 Inch is the one to reach for.

How We Picked

We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.

Sources & Methodology

Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of July 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.

As an Amazon Associate, Gadgets Feed earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.

Related Guides

Please use a real email you check. If it's fake or mistyped, your message won't reach us and we can't reply — wrong addresses are rejected automatically.