Our readers keep the lights on and my morning glass full of iced black tea. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.7 Best 1-1/2 Inch Ear Gauges | 38mm Real Stone vs Steel Tunnel

Check Price on Amazon

These are the single most commented-on piece of body jewelry at this size. Each plug features embedded miniature watch gears and components sealed under a clear domed face, all set into a 316L stainless steel body. The 38mm double-flare version wears with a satisfying heft that feels substantial without being punishing—reviewers note it gets as much attention as much pricier gold jewelry.

Fit is reported as true to size with a snug double-flare retention that holds during daily activity. The steel construction means no reactions for most wearers, and the internal detail is fully encapsulated so no small parts can detach. This is not a subtle plug—it’s meant to be seen and discussed.

The wearable area accommodates average to moderately thick lobes. At this price point within the premium bracket, you’re paying for the hand-assembled craftsmanship and the fact that each pair has slight variations in gear placement, making yours truly one-of-a-kind.

Check Price on Amazon

Natural stone at 38mm is a commitment, and these aventurine plugs deliver on the rich, variegated green color that organic stone lovers seek. The double-flare design is cut from genuine jade green aventurine, meaning each pair has unique veining and translucency—no two sets are identical. The surface is polished to a smooth, cool-to-the-touch finish.

Wearers with thicker lobes will appreciate that the wearable area is generous, though the natural stone density means these are noticeably weighty. Some users at 32mm reported soreness after full-day wear, so at 38mm expect a similar experience—they are best reserved for shorter outings or days when you want the aesthetic impact. The stone is porous, so avoid prolonged moisture exposure.

Sizing consistency has been praised overall, with one caveat: a small number of buyers received pieces that ran slightly under-size and slipped out easily. Ordering the next size up is a common workaround if your lobes are on the thinner side. The packaging is secure, and the set arrives with paired stones that are well-matched in color.

Check Price on Amazon

For a clean, lightweight everyday tunnel that won’t break the bank, these PVD-coated 316L tunnels from Pierced Owl are a strong contender. The Physical Vapor Deposition coating gives them a deep, uniform matte black finish that resists scratching and chipping better than painted alternatives. At 38mm, the double-flare design holds securely, and the thin wall profile keeps the weight minimal.

Reviewers consistently mention the fit is on point and that these tunnels rarely fall out during the day, though some with thicker lobes note the flare is slightly less pronounced than other plugs, which can lead to slippage during sleep. The smooth edges are a highlight—no sharp transitions to irritate the fistula. The PVD finish has held up well for long-term users, with no reports of silver metal showing through.

These are an excellent choice if you want a no-fuss, modern look that blends with any outfit. The lack of O-rings simplifies insertion and removal, and the 316L base metal ensures compatibility with sensitive skin. They are among the lightest tunnels at this size, making them ideal for all-day wear at work or school.

Check Price on Amazon

LADEMAYH’s saddle-shaped plugs offer two pairs in one package, giving you style variety without multiplying the cost. The saddle design—a tunnel with a curved top that accepts a small hoop earring through the center—is a clever way to layer jewelry. The base material is 316L surgical stainless steel, so nickel sensitivity reactions are rare.

Customer feedback is overwhelmingly positive on the compliments these generate. The finish is available in multiple colors including gold, which reviewers say pairs well with other facial piercings. Fit is generally true to size, though a handful of users note they run slightly small. The weight is moderate—not as heavy as solid stone, but denser than thin-walled tunnels.

The main trade-off is the wearable area: at larger sizes the saddle groove can be shallower, which may reduce how securely a hoop sits. Additionally, the design inherently has a front and back orientation, so you need to pay attention when inserting. For anyone wanting to experiment with the saddle look at 38mm without committing to a single expensive pair, this two-pack is the logical entry point.

Check Price on Amazon

If your style leans toward elegant or formal, these white pearl shell plugs from BOKABOO bring a refined, iridescent finish that catches light beautifully. Each plug features a genuine shell face set into a 316L stainless steel base with screw-on backs—a single-flare design that lets you adjust tightness. The two-pair value pack covers different shell tones for wardrobe matching.

The screw-on mechanism is a key differentiator: unlike double-flare plugs that rely on lobe tightness, these stay put regardless of your lobe elasticity. The wearable area is listed at 6mm, which is on the narrower side. Users with thicker lobes have confirmed it fits but barely, so measure your lobe thickness before purchasing. The overall weight is moderate, though some reviewers find them heavy for daily wear.

Aesthetics are the main draw here—the shell has a subtle shimmer that looks especially good in sunlight or under warm indoor lighting. The metal components are well-finished with no sharp threads. A small number of users report minor earlobe irritation after several consecutive days, which may be due to moisture trapped between the shell and the metal base rather than the metal itself.

Check Price on Amazon

For a straightforward, solid black stone plug at a competitive price point, Pierced Owl’s black obsidian offering is hard to beat. The double-flare design is cut from natural obsidian, giving a deep, glossy black that works with any wardrobe. The stone has a satisfying heft—users describe it as feeling substantial without being uncomfortable for the first few hours of wear.

Fit is reported as true to size with a snug double-flare that, for most wearers, stays in place during physical activity. However, the saddle is described as shallow by some, and combined with the stone’s density, a few users report that the plugs can slip out during sleep or when turning the head quickly. The stone’s natural coolness is a nice sensory detail, especially in warmer weather.

Durability is the main consideration here: obsidian is volcanic glass, and while it’s tough, a drop onto a hard surface like tile or marble can crack or shatter the plug. Multiple reviews confirm this. If you’re careful with storage and handling, these offer a classic look at a budget-friendly price for natural stone. They are not recommended for sleeping due to both weight and potential for loss.

Check Price on Amazon

Silicone is the lightest material option available, making these virtually weightless in the ear. They are flexible enough to compress for insertion, which is a major advantage for lobes that aren’t perfectly loose.

The main use case for silicone tunnels is comfort during sleep, exercise, or any situation where rigid jewelry is a nuisance. Multiple reviewers confirm they stay in place overnight due to the flexible lip that grips the fistula. The material is non-porous and hypoallergenic, though new silicone can feel slightly tacky—a light application of jojoba oil or lotion solves this after the first wear.

Durability is limited compared to steel or stone; silicone will degrade over months of daily use, especially if exposed to harsh chemicals or extreme heat. The colors are vibrant, and each tunnel has a decent flare that holds well for average lobe thickness. If you want to build a large color rotation at 38mm without spending a fortune, this set is the most cost-effective route available.