Our readers keep the lights on and my morning glass full of iced black tea. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
Every 67XL cartridge promises more pages, but the real difference between a refill and a frustrating paperweight is whether your printer actually recognizes the chip inside. This guide breaks down the genuine HP cartridges versus the remanufactured alternatives, so you know exactly which one works with your DeskJet or Envy before you click buy.
I’m Min — the founder and writer behind Gadgets Feed. This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
If you are tired of swapping cartridges mid-project, the honest truth is that page yield numbers and chip compatibility matter more than brand loyalty when choosing 67xl printer ink.
Our Picks at a Glance
How To Choose The Best 67XL Printer Ink
Buying 67XL ink is not just about picking the cheapest bottle. You need to match the cartridge type to your printer model, decide between genuine and remanufactured, and understand the page yield so you are not back at the store in two weeks.
Genuine HP vs. Remanufactured vs. Compatible
Genuine HP cartridges are engineered with original chips that your printer recognizes instantly, which is why they never throw “non-genuine” errors. Remanufactured and compatible options reuse or rebuild shells with new chips — they cost less per cartridge but occasionally fail to communicate with specific printer firmware.
Page Yield: The Real Cost Per Page
The “XL” designation is all about volume. A genuine HP 67XL black cartridge yields about 240 pages, while several compatible brands push that number to 750 pages per cartridge at 5% coverage. If you print frequently, that gap means you replace the cartridge far less often, which saves you time and money in the long run.
Chip Compatibility and Printer Recognition
Your printer reads a tiny chip on the cartridge to track ink levels. If the chip’s firmware does not match your printer’s model list, you will see an error message and the cartridge will not work. Always check the model list in the product description — especially for “e” series printers that activate HP+ service.
Quick Comparison
| Model | Best For | Page Yield | Cartridge Type | Pack Size | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HP 67XL Black (Genuine)★ Best Overall | Guaranteed recognition | 240 pages | Genuine | 1 | Amazon |
| XJI 67XL 2-PackBest Value Refill | Budget black refills | 700 pages | Remanufactured | 2 | Amazon |
| myCartridge SUPRINT 2-PackHigh-Yield Champion | High-volume black printing | 750 pages | Compatible | 2 | Amazon |
| NVN 67XL 2-Pack | High-yield with HP+ support | 750 pages | Compatible | 2 | Amazon |
| Chromojet 67XL 2-Pack | Clean black text for DeskJets | 700 pages | Compatible | 2 | Amazon |
| TOKYOINK 67XL 2-Pack | Eco-conscious remanufactured | 750 pages | Remanufactured | 2 | Amazon |
| Cool Toner 67XL Combo | Black + color combo | Black 750 / Color 450 | Compatible | 2 | Amazon |
| HP 67XL Tri-Color (Genuine) | Vibrant color prints | 200 pages | Genuine | 1 | Amazon |
| Oillike 67XL Combo | Budget color and black | Black 700 / Color 450 | Remanufactured | 2 | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. HP 67XL Black High-Yield Ink Cartridge
Our pick — over 4.5★ from 54,000+ verified ratings; the strongest balance of quality and price.
The genuine HP cartridge that slides in without a single error message.
The genuine HP chip is recognized instantly by DeskJet and Envy printers, eliminating “non-genuine” errors. Buyers report the printer reads it immediately — no “non-genuine” alerts, no firmware fights — which is exactly what you want when you are mid-print. It is engineered for the DeskJet 1255, 2700, 4100 series and Envy 6000, 6400 series, so the compatibility list is long and reliable.
Its 240-page yield is lower than compatible 750-page packs, but the trade-off is flawless recognition and consistent print quality. Owners rave about the ink quality, with crisp, sharp text that holds up on standard documents and high-detail grayscale prints. Some owners question the premium price, but the reliability justifies it for those who prioritize zero-error printing.
It works with HP Instant Ink, auto-shipping replacements when levels run low. For HP+ enabled printers, this is the safest choice to avoid third-party chip error screens.
What wins buyers over
- Perfect recognition with HP printers — no setup headaches
- Sharp, professional print quality for everyday documents
- Eligible for HP Instant Ink subscription
What gives some pause
- 240-page yield is low compared to compatible 750-page packs
- Premium price per page versus remanufactured options
The safe pick: Choose this if you never want to troubleshoot a cartridge error again.
Consider alternatives: If you print hundreds of pages monthly and want to cut costs, you will pay more per page here.
2. XJI 67XL Printer Ink Replacement (2-Pack)
A 2-pack of black ink that undercuts the genuine price per page.
XJI’s pitch is simple: you get two 67XL black cartridges in one box, each delivering up to 700 pages at 5% coverage. That is roughly triple the pages of a single genuine HP 67XL, which makes this the obvious choice for high-volume black-and-white printing on a budget.
Owners consistently note the value for money — “they work fine and are cheaper than OEM” is the recurring sentiment. Installation is easy, and the cartridges last a decent while before running dry. The catch is compatibility: a vocal subset of owners mention the cartridge does not work in HP 6700-series printers, showing an error that the black cartridge is empty even when freshly installed. If your printer is a DeskJet 2700, 2800, 4100, or 4200 series model, you are likely fine; if it is an older or less common model, check the list first.
The latest chips track ink levels, but mixed recognition feedback makes this risky for users who cannot tolerate a failed install.
Cost per page winner: The 700-page yield per cartridge at this price point makes it the cheapest way to keep a busy home office printing.
Reach for this if: You burn through black ink fast and want two cartridges ready to swap.
Look elsewhere if: Your printer model is not explicitly listed — the compatibility errors are real for some owners.
3. myCartridge SUPRINT 67XL Black Ink Cartridge (2-Pack)
Up to 750 pages per cartridge, backed by a 24-month replacement promise.
This 2-pack from myCartridge SUPRINT leads the yield race at 750 pages per black cartridge at 5% coverage — the highest claim on this list. For a home office that churns out documents, that means fewer cartridge swaps and a lower cost per print over time.
The standout feature is the “upgraded chip” designed to let you monitor ink levels and ensure compatibility with HP+ registered printers. Owners praise the ink quality — deep, crisp black with clean grayscale — and installation is straightforward. But compatibility is where the reviews split: some HP Envy customers note the printer recognized the cartridge immediately without any “non-genuine” alerts, while others hit a wall where the printer rejected both cartridges entirely.
A 24-month after-sales service promises replacement if a cartridge fails. The warranty eases the reliability gamble, though some buyers still report faulty units the printer rejects.
Yield leader: At 750 pages per cartridge, this 2-pack holds a 3.1x page advantage over the genuine HP single cartridge.
Best if: You want maximum pages per dollar and a warranty that covers duds.
Think twice if: Your printer is strict about third-party chips — recognition failures are the main complaint.
4. NVN 67XL Black Ink Cartridge (2-Pack)
Designed for the newer “e” series printers that run HP+ service.
NVN markets this 2-pack specifically toward owners of “e” series printers that have activated HP+ service — the models that often reject standard third-party cartridges. Each cartridge delivers up to 750 pages at 5% coverage, positioning it alongside the highest-yield options here.
The intelligent chip (a small circuit that talks to your printer) promises smooth compatibility with DeskJet 2700, 4100 series and Envy 6000 series printers. Owners generally love the ink volume — “a ton of ink to print a ton of whatever you need” is a repeated theme — and many say they will buy again. The value for money is the most-praised aspect, but printer compatibility draws mixed reviews. Some printers throw an error message on every install even while printing fine, and a few reviewers point out the cartridge simply stops working after a short time.
If you have a DeskJet 1255, 2755e, or 2855e, the integrated chip should communicate ink levels properly. But if your printer is particularly picky, the error messages might be a constant annoyance.
What stands out
- 750-page yield per cartridge for extended printing sessions
- Built for HP+ activated “e” series printers
- Intelligent chip tracks ink levels accurately
What to watch
- Some printers send error messages even when printing works
- Compatibility is not guaranteed across all listed models
Choose this if: You have an “e” series printer and want high yield without paying genuine prices.
skip it if: You cannot tolerate occasional error prompts — the recognition is not flawless.
5. Chromojet 67XL Black Ink Cartridge (2-Pack)
A straightforward 2-pack focused on clean, sharp black text.
Chromojet keeps things simple: two 67XL black cartridges, each yielding up to 700 pages at 5% coverage on A4 paper. The brand is not chasing color accuracy or combo packs — it is built for the person who mostly prints text documents and wants reliability.
Print quality is the most-praised feature, with owners calling the output easy to install and great for everyday use. The compatibility list is broad, covering DeskJet 2700, 2800, 4100, 4200 series and Envy 6000, 6400 series printers. The honest caveat is the same one that follows most third-party ink: a portion of buyers find the cartridge triggers a “not compatible” error on their specific printer model, even though the listing claims it should work.
The brand explicitly reminds buyers to verify their printer model against the list before purchasing — a rare admission that compatibility is not universal. For owners of the most common DeskJet and Envy models, this is a dependable, low-cost black ink solution.
Text-first value: If your printing is 90% black text, this 2-pack delivers solid quality without paying for color features you will not use.
Reach for this if: You want a no-frills black ink 2-pack that prints crisp documents.
Look elsewhere if: Your printer model is not on the extensive compatibility list — errors are possible.
6. TOKYOINK 67XL Ink Compatible for HP (2-Pack)
ISO-certified remanufactured ink with a 2-year safeguard promise.
TOKYOINK stands out for its quality assurance credentials. The cartridges undergo strict inspection and carry ISO9001 and ISO14001 certifications, plus a 2-year safeguard with 24/7 customer service and a 100% exchange policy for defective units. For a remanufactured product, that is an unusually strong safety net.
Each of the two black cartridges yields up to 750 pages at 5% coverage, matching the highest claims on this list. Owners praise the ink quality and value for money, and one thoughtful touch is the included bag to send back old cartridges for recycling — a nice nod to the environmental angle. Installation is easy, and the cartridges align properly with the printer.
Compatibility is the mixed note, as with most remanufactured options. The bulk of shoppers say flawless performance, but a subset finds their specific printer refuses the cartridge. The 2-year warranty mitigates the risk — if it fails, the seller promises to make it right.
The reassuring bits
- ISO9001 and ISO14001 certified manufacturing process
- 2-year safeguard with 100% exchange for defects
- 750-page yield per cartridge at a budget price
The honest catch
- Some printers still reject the remanufactured chip
- Recognition is not as universal as genuine HP
Best if: You want the cost savings of remanufactured ink with a real warranty backing it.
Think twice if: Your printer is known to be strict about third-party cartridges.
7. Cool Toner 67XL Black/Color Combo Pack
One black and one tri-color cartridge, ready for mixed printing.
If you print both documents and the occasional photo or colored chart, this combo pack gives you one 67XL black (750 pages) and one 67XL tri-color (450 pages) cartridge in a single purchase. It is the convenience of a full setup without buying two separate packs.
Compatibility is the most-praised aspect by a wide margin, with owners reporting the cartridges fit perfectly into their HP printers and work as well as name-brand ink. The color output earns specific praise for vibrancy, clarity, and smudge resistance — rare for a compatible product. Installation is easy enough that owners note even kids can swap them in.
The ink life draws mixed feedback, which is the main honest caveat. Some report the cartridges last longer than average, while others say a cartridge runs dry in under 20 days of heavy use. For light to moderate printing, this is a strong value; for relentless daily volume, the yield claims may fall short of reality.
All-around convenience: A single order covers both black and color needs with page yields that beat the genuine HP tri-color by a wide margin.
Choose this if: You want a balanced black-and-color setup from one box.
pass on it if: You print constantly — some buyers report cartridges draining faster than the 750-page claim.
8. HP 67XL Tri-Color High-Yield Ink Cartridge (Genuine)
Genuine tri-color ink that prints true-to-life photos from the start.
HP’s genuine tri-color cartridge delivers cyan, magenta, and yellow inks engineered specifically for HP printers, which means the color profile is calibrated for sharp, vibrant output. Owners consistently praise the quality — “reliable, legit, high quality ink” is a common refrain — and installation takes about a minute with instant recognition.
The yield is about 200 pages, which is modest next to the compatible combo packs that claim 450 pages for color. But you are paying for consistency and perfect print quality, not raw volume. The printer recognizes the cartridge immediately, works with the HP 2827e and the full DeskJet 1255, 2700, 4100 series plus Envy 6000, 6400 series, and is eligible for Instant Ink subscriptions.
Value for money is the split point. Some owners find it cost-effective, while others note there is no real savings versus buying in stores. If color accuracy and zero-fuss installation matter more than squeezing every last page, this is the cartridge to trust.
The genuine advantages
- Instant recognition with HP printers — no setup issues
- Excellent color output for photos and graphics
- Eligible for HP Instant Ink program
The honest trade-off
- 200-page yield is low compared to compatible color cartridges
- Premium price with no significant savings over retail
Pick this if: You print photos or colored graphics and refuse to compromise on output quality.
Consider alternatives: If you print color rarely, a compatible combo pack offers far more pages per dollar.
9. Oillike 67XL Ink Cartridges Black/Color Combo Pack
A remanufactured duo that claims up to 3x more prints than standard HP.
Oillike’s combo pack includes a black cartridge rated for 700 pages and a tri-color rated for 450 pages, both at 5% coverage. The brand uses premium ink and recycled plastic, with approvals from CE, REACH, ISO 9001, ISO 14001, and ISO 14067 certificates — a solid environmental and quality pedigree for a budget option.
The most-praised aspects are fit and ease of installation. Owners mention the cartridges snap into place and align properly, with several noting the quality matches original HP ink at a cheaper price. The value duo format — one black and one color — is a draw for people who want both without ordering two separate packs.
This is where the honest caveats pile up. Print quality is the most-mentioned aspect but draws mixed reviews — some owners get excellent results while others find it unsatisfactory. Compatibility is flagged as a genuine concern, with a notable share of buyers reporting their printers refuse to accept the cartridges entirely. One owner went so far as to call the “XL” claim false advertising, alleging the cartridges last far shorter than regular HP. If you have a picky printer, this is the riskiest pick on the list.
The budget gamble: The page yields and price are attractive, but the mixed print quality and compatibility issues make this a coin flip on some printers.
Reach for this if: You want the cheapest possible black-and-color duo and your printer is on the explicit compatibility list.
Look elsewhere if: You cannot risk a failed install or subpar color output — the reviews are genuinely split here.
Understanding the Specs
Page Yield
Page yield tells you how many pages a cartridge prints before running dry, measured at a standard 5% coverage — roughly a page of plain text. A 240-page yield handles light home printing, while 700 to 750-page cartridges suit busy offices. Note that printing photos or dense graphics drains ink far faster than the stated yield.
Smart Chip Recognition
Every 67XL cartridge carries a chip that tells your printer its ink levels and authenticity. Genuine HP chips are recognized instantly. Compatible and remanufactured chips need to match your printer’s firmware — when they do not, you see a “non-genuine” or “cannot read” error. The chip compatibility is the single biggest reason a third-party cartridge fails.
Genuine vs. Remanufactured
Genuine HP cartridges are factory-built and guaranteed to work with your printer, which is why they cost more. Remanufactured cartridges are recycled and refilled with new ink and chips — cheaper, but with a higher chance of recognition issues. Compatible cartridges are new builds designed to replace HP, offering high yield at a low price with the same chip-risk trade-off.
Ink Base and Print Quality
The ink base matters for output quality. Water-based inks are standard for everyday document printing and dry fast. Oil-based inks are sometimes used in remanufactured cartridges for richer colors. Always check whether the cartridge uses premium ink and recycled plastic, as these affect both the print sharpness and the environmental footprint.
FAQ
Will a 67XL cartridge work in my HP DeskJet 2755e?
What is the difference between 67 and 67XL ink cartridges?
Why does my printer say the cartridge is not genuine?
How many pages does a 67XL black cartridge print?
Can I use 67XL ink with HP Instant Ink?
Does 67XL ink work in HP Envy 6000 series printers?
Why does my remanufactured cartridge show empty when installed?
Is compatible 67XL ink as good as genuine HP ink?
What does 5% coverage mean for page yield?
Can I install a 67XL cartridge in a printer that normally uses 67?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
If you want one dependable pick, the 67xl printer ink winner is the HP 67XL Black because it is the one cartridge that never makes you gamble on compatibility — it is the crowd favorite among tens of thousands of owners for its instant recognition and sharp print quality. If you want maximum pages per dollar, grab the myCartridge SUPRINT 2-Pack with its 750-page per cartridge yield. And for those who print both color and black, the Cool Toner Combo Pack is the one to reach for — it delivers a full setup in a single box.
How We Picked
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources & Methodology
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of August 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, Gadgets Feed earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.