A broadhead’s razor-sharp blades slice through standard foam targets in a few sessions, turning your practice block into a shredded mess that won’t stop an arrow. That’s the hard reality of tuning expandables or fixed-blade heads — the target must absorb the cut while gripping the shaft for clean removal, a balance that cheap layered foam fails to deliver.
I’m Min — the co-founder and writer behind Gadgets Feed. My deep dive into the raw data and user reviews across dozens of archery targets reveals exactly which models manage the dual demands of stopping high-velocity broadheads without destroying themselves.
Whether you shoot a compound bow or a high-FPS crossbow, selecting the right archery target for broadheads means looking for self-healing foam, multi-sided shooting surfaces, and a density that prevents pass-throughs while still allowing two-finger arrow removal.
How To Choose The Best Archery Target For Broadheads
A broadhead target is a fundamentally different product from a field-point bag. The blades slice fibers rather than punch through them, which means the target must be made of a material that can “hold” the cut closed after the arrow is removed. Cheap, low-density foam erodes fast; the wrong choice leaves you buying a new block every few weeks.
Self-Healing Foam vs. Layered Fiber
Self-healing polyurethane foam is the gold standard for broadhead targets. When the blades pass through, the foam’s molecular structure re-bonds, sealing the cut and maintaining density for hundreds of shots. Layered fiber or compressed fabric targets rely on friction — they stop arrows fine but leave gaps that widen with each broadhead impact, eventually leading to pass-throughs.
Stopping Power and FPS Rating
Every target lists a maximum velocity in feet per second (FPS). A target rated for 350 FPS will struggle with a 400 FPS crossbow bolt carrying a mechanical broadhead. Overrating your bow speed against the target’s limit causes blown-out exit holes and premature failure. Always buy a target rated at least 50 FPS above your bow’s advertised IBO speed.
Multi-Sided Design and Replacement Covers
Broadheads chew up the face faster than field points — a target with four or six useable sides effectively quadruples its lifespan before the foam degrades. Models with replaceable covers add even more value, letting you swap a worn face without buying a whole new block. Look for contrasting aiming points on different sides to separate broadhead and field-point practice.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Category | Best For | Key Spec | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rinehart 18-1 | Premium Cube | Broadhead tuning & hunting practice | 500 FPS rating, self-healing foam | Amazon |
| Morrell High Roller | Premium Cube | High-speed crossbow & compound | 450 FPS rating, 6-sided design | Amazon |
| Morrell Yellow Jacket Dual Threat | Mid-Range Combo | Field points and broadheads in one block | 350 FPS rating, fused cellular foam | Amazon |
| Delta McKenzie 18″ | Mid-Range Bag | Crossbow discharge & travel practice | 400+ FPS rating, compact bag | Amazon |
| Black Hole Crossbow 16″ | Value Layered | Versatile 4-sided target on a budget | 375 FPS rating, open-face layered design | Amazon |
| Shooter Field Logic 3D Hog | Budget 3D | 3D realism practice on a budget | 60-70 lb draw, lightweight plastic | Amazon |
In‑Depth Reviews
1. Rinehart 18-1 Archery Target
The Rinehart 18-1 is the benchmark for broadhead-specific targets. Its solid self-healing foam stops a 150-grain Cutthroat broadhead fired from a 68-pound draw compound bow at 30 inches of draw length without a pass-through — a feat that destroys most layered targets in under a dozen shots. The cube shape gives you 18 useable faces, which translates to years of broadhead tuning before the foam loses its grip.
Lightweight enough to carry one-handed to the range or hunting camp, yet dense enough to show the exact angle of your arrow for rest tuning adjustments. Users shooting 550-grain arrows report consistent stopping power even after seven years of regular use. The foam is self-healing, so broadhead slits close up rather than widening into permanent channels.
The primary downside is that the 15-inch cube is compact — errant shots near the bottom edge can pass through. Also, the paint job is functional rather than pretty, with aiming zones that fade. But for pure broadhead performance, nothing in this roundup matches the Rinehart’s durability and field-proven track record.
Why it’s great
- True self-healing foam stops even heavy broadheads without pass-through
- 18 sides extend target life dramatically compared to 4-sided blocks
- Light at 11 pounds with a carry handle for easy transport
Good to know
- Compact 15-inch size means edge hits can blow through
- Paint wears off quickly; you’ll need to re-mark aiming zones
- Arrow pull requires some effort, especially at higher draw weights
2. Morrell High Roller Foam Archery Target
The Morrell High Roller is engineered for the high-velocity crowd, rated to stop arrows up to 450 FPS. That makes it one of the few targets in this list that can confidently handle a modern crossbow shooting 400+ FPS bolts with mechanical broadheads. The self-healing high-density foam seals itself after each shot, and users report that even after dozens of broadhead impacts, the face remains tight.
With 21 bullseyes spread across six sides, you get variety without needing to hang multiple targets. The 13-inch depth provides enough stopping mass that a 400 FPS bolt from an elevated 15-yard shot embeds without exiting. The heavy 12-pound weight keeps the target planted — it doesn’t spin or slide around on impact, which is a common complaint with lighter blocks.
Arrow removal can be tough, especially with broadheads that have cut a deep channel. A double-D arrow puller is recommended. The target is also on the heavier side for transporting, though the EZ-tote handle helps. If you shoot a high-FPS crossbow and want a premium target that won’t degrade after a single season, this is your pick.
Why it’s great
- 450 FPS rating handles the fastest crossbows and compounds
- Self-healing foam seals broadhead cuts effectively
- 21 bullseyes on 6 sides for diverse practice sessions
Good to know
- Heavy at 12 pounds; not the easiest to haul around
- Arrow removal can require significant effort without a puller
- Broadheads will visibly mar the painted circles over time
3. Morrell Yellow Jacket Dual Threat
The Yellow Jacket Dual Threat occupies a sweet spot: mid-range cost but high-end feature density. Its fused cellular foam is specifically optimized for both field points and broadheads, meaning you can switch between practice tips and expandables on the same block without destroying the surface. Rated for 350 FPS, it handles most compound bows and slower crossbows without pass-through.
Users with 80-pound draw compound bows shooting 300+ FPS report penetration of just 6-7 inches, leaving plenty of stopping mass. The weather-resistant surface means you can leave it outside without the foam degrading from moisture, and the easy-carry handle makes it portable enough for range trips. At roughly the size of a small cooler, it fits easily in a trunk or truck bed.
The trade-off is that arrow removal is genuinely difficult, especially with broadheads. Multiple reviews mention needing a double-D puller and considerable upper-body strength. The foam is dense — that’s what stops the arrows so effectively — but it also grips the shaft hard. If you have a crossbow over 350 FPS, you need the High Roller or Rinehart instead.
Why it’s great
- Purpose-built for both field points and broadheads in one block
- Weather-resistant foam holds up to outdoor storage
- No pass-throughs for compound bows up to 80 pounds
Good to know
- Arrow removal is tough; a puller is essentially mandatory
- 350 FPS rating limits crossbow compatibility
- Lightweight design means it can slide on hard surfaces on impact
4. Delta McKenzie 18″ Standard Block Target
The Delta McKenzie 18-inch target is a compact bag-style block that punches above its size. Despite being roughly a foot square, it stops crossbow bolts traveling over 400 FPS with ease, making it an excellent choice for unloading a crossbow after a hunt or for backyard practice sessions. The bag construction uses layered fabric rather than solid foam, which gives it a distinct feel — arrows pull out cleanly without the wrestling match common with dense foam cubes.
Users shooting 375 FPS bolts report full stopping power with no damage to fletching, and the small footprint makes it ideal for limited practice spaces. It’s also compatible with broadheads on all sides, adding versatility. The integrated handles make carrying simple, and the price point is reasonable for a target that can handle high-speed crossbows.
Durability is a concern: after roughly 50 shots, the metal rings that hold the bag together at the bottom can show strain, and the fabric may wear faster than a foam block. It’s also small — not ideal for long-range practice where arrow groups spread wider than the face. For a dedicated close-range or discharge target, though, it’s hard to beat.
Why it’s great
- Stops 400+ FPS crossbow bolts in a compact package
- Arrow removal is clean and easy compared to foam blocks
- Portable and ideal for use as a discharge target afield
Good to know
- Bag construction may wear faster than solid foam targets
- Small 18-inch face limits use for long-range practice
- Metal bottom rings can loosen over time
5. Black Hole 4-Sided Crossbow Archery Target
The Black Hole target uses a unique open-face layered design where the sides are exposed layers of material that stop arrows through friction rather than brute density. This allows the 16x16x14-inch block to stop crossbow bolts up to 375 FPS while keeping the weight down to 13 pounds. The friction-based stopping power also means arrow removal is easier than with dense foam — though users of high-speed crossbows still recommend a rubber jar opener or puller for the hardest-pulled arrows.
A clever feature is the 4-sided design: two wrapped sides optimized for field points, and two open-face layered sides for broadheads and expandables. This separation lets you preserve your field-point side for daily practice while saving the broadhead sides for tuning sessions. The carry handle makes it portable, and the Made in USA construction adds confidence.
The main limitation is the 375 FPS cap—crossbows shooting faster will blow through. Additionally, the “easy one-handed removal” advertised is optimistic for high-speed bolts; most users need two hands and some technique. For compound bow shooters or crossbow owners with sub-375 FPS rigs, this is an excellent budget-friendly choice.
Why it’s great
- 4-sided design with dedicated broadhead and field point faces
- Friction-based layering allows easier arrow removal than dense foam
- Lightweight and portable with a convenient carry handle
Good to know
- 375 FPS rating excludes high-speed crossbows
- Arrow removal can still require significant effort with fast bolts
- Layered material may degrade faster than solid foam with heavy use
6. Shooter Field Logic 3D Hog Target
The Shooter Field Logic 3D Hog is a budget-friendly way to add realistic animal anatomy to your broadhead practice. Its plastic core and lightweight construction make arrows pull out easily — a major advantage over dense foam blocks. The realistic hog shape lets you practice shot placement, aiming for the vital zone just behind the shoulder, which is critical for hunting preparation.
After hundreds of shots with a 60-pound bow, the target holds up well, with field points passing just over halfway through the body. The finish and detail are impressive for the price point. Users appreciate that it’s inexpensive enough to treat as a disposable practice tool while still delivering decent longevity.
Two significant caveats: the hard plastic core sits close to the kill zone, meaning a miss by just a few inches toward the shoulder will shatter an arrow on impact. And despite being marketed as broadhead-compatible, the lightweight construction makes it questionable for repeated broadhead use — the blades may cut through the thin body material faster than field points. Use it primarily for field point practice on realistic 3D forms, and reserve broadheads for dedicated foam blocks.
Why it’s great
- Affordable entry into 3D target practice with realistic anatomy
- Easy arrow removal with field points
- Lightweight and simple to transport to the field
Good to know
- Hard internal core can shatter arrows on shoulder hits
- Not truly durable for extensive broadhead use
- Smaller than expected; shot placement margin is tight
FAQ
Can I shoot broadheads into a regular field point bag target?
How many shots should a broadhead target last before needing replacement?
What’s the difference between a crossbow target and a compound bow target for broadheads?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most users, the archery target for broadheads winner is the Rinehart 18-1 because it combines true self-healing foam, 18 useable sides, and proven stopping power for heavy broadheads at any draw weight. If you want a dedicated high-speed crossbow block, grab the Morrell High Roller with its 450 FPS rating and 6-sided design. And for the best value on a target that handles both field points and broadheads, the Morrell Yellow Jacket Dual Threat delivers reliable performance at a mid-range price point.