Our readers keep the lights on and my morning glass full of iced black tea. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Specs are compiled from manufacturer listings and verified buyer reviews and can change over time — please confirm the key details on the product page before buying.
You need an arrow that survives wet hands, a muddy bank, and a fish that thrashes the second it hits the deck. That is the whole job. Bowfishing arrows are short, heavy, solid shafts built to be pulled back through water and hauled in by a line, and a target arrow will not do that work. The picks below cover every real choice in this shelf, from a single replacement shaft to multi-packs that keep you shooting after you lose one to a stump.
I’m Min — the founder and writer behind Gadgets Feed. This guide is built by comparing the manufacturers’ published specifications and the patterns across verified customer reviews, so you get each pick’s real strengths and trade-offs instead of marketing spin.
Short shafts, glue-fixed nocks, and safety slides doing the heavy lifting are the three things that decide whether your evening on the water ends early. This breakdown of bowfishing arrows covers shaft length, weight, and tip style so you buy the right set once.
Our Picks at a Glance
How To Choose The Best Bowfishing Arrows
Most first-timers grab a set because it looks tough in the photo, then find out on the water that the nock spins, the slide binds, or the shaft is too long for their bow. These three checks sort the shelf fast.
Shaft length has to match your bow, not your height
Bowfishing arrows are deliberately short so the point sits forward of your bow grip without overhanging the rest. A 32 inch shaft is the shorter end of this shelf, while a 37.5 inch shaft is the longest pick here. Measure from your arrow rest forward, not from your draw length on a target bow, because a shaft that hangs past the rest catches on the string on release.
Solid fiberglass beats hollow tube for one reason: it does not float away
A solid glass shaft sinks and stays put when it misses, where a hollow tube can float off and cost you the shot. Solid glass also takes a hit against a rock without splitting along the wall. The trade-off is weight — these shafts run heavy, which slows flight but drives penetration through scales and water.
Look at the slide and nock before anything else
The safety slide is the ring your line runs through, and it is what stops a tethered arrow from snapping back into your face if the line snags. A stopper behind it keeps the slide from riding up the shaft. On the nock side, several sets here fix the nock with glue, so check that before you buy — a glued nock cannot be swapped if it cracks.
Quick Comparison
| Model | Best For | Shaft Material | Length | Pack Size | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Muzzy Classic Fiberglass Fish Arrow★ Best Overall | Best overall for a first serious setup | Fiberglass | 37.5 inches | 1 | Amazon |
| TIGER ARCHERY 34inch Glow ShaftBest Value | Night shooting and best value per arrow | Solid fiberglass | 34.8 inches | 6 | Amazon |
| Muzzy Lighted Carbon CompositeTop Performer | Low-light shots with a lit nock | 80% fiberglass / 20% carbon | — | 1 | Amazon |
| OBTOUTDOOR 36 Inch 8mm | Longer reach on big water | Glass fiber | 36 inches | 6 | Amazon |
| AMEYXGS Luminous Fiberglass | Night bowfishing with a glow shaft | Fiberglass | — | 6 | Amazon |
| RUOERSI 34 inch 2 Pack | A spare pair for a light kit | Fiberglass | 34 inches | 2 | Amazon |
| AMEYXGS 6/12pcs Fiberglass | Casual bowfishing trips with a full quiver | Fiberglass | — | 6 | Amazon |
| NIKA ARCHERY 32 Inch | A compact pack of three | Solid fiberglass | 32 inches | 3 | Amazon |
| GPP 32 Inch 6 Pack | Volume shooting on a tight budget | Solid fiberglass | 32 inches | 6 | Amazon |
In-Depth Reviews
1. Muzzy Classic Fiberglass Bowfishing Fish Arrow with Nock and Bottle Slide Installed
Our pick — 4.0+★ from 250+ verified ratings; the strongest balance of quality and price.
A ready-to-shoot single arrow that arrives with the slide already threaded on.
Here is a 37.5 inch solid fiberglass shaft that shows up with the bottle slide installed and the carp point already on. You unwrap it, tie your line to the slide, and shoot.
The weight is where this one separates itself. At 4 ounces it carries real mass into the water, which is what pushes a barbed point through a carp’s back instead of bouncing off it. Compared to the lighter RUOERSI shafts at 100 g, the Muzzy puts more of your bow’s energy into the fish and less into drag.
The one thing to plan around: this is a single arrow. You are buying one shaft, so budget for a spare or two if you shoot rocky banks, because a solid glass shaft that hits a rock head-on at full draw can chip at the tip end. The upside is that this is a proven, well-known carp setup with a slide that stays where it should — what wins people over here is that it needs no assembly from the start.
What Earns Its Place First
- Bottle slide and carp point arrive already installed, so it is shootable the moment you tie on a line.
- 37.5 inches of solid fiberglass gives you the longest shaft on this list for a forward-of-the-grip setup.
- 4 ounces of shaft weight drives penetration through water and scales.
- A classic Muzzy carp setup that bowfishers recognize and trust.
Where It Asks More Of You
- Sold as one arrow — no backup in the package.
- White shaft is easy to see in daylight and harder to track at night.
- Longer shaft can overhang a short arrow rest.
Buy this if: you want one arrow that arrives ready and you plan to shoot carp from a boat or bank at night with a line tied on.
Add a spare if: you shoot rocky shallows — a single arrow means one bad hit ends your evening.
2. TIGER ARCHERY 34inch Bowfishing Arrows Solid Fiberglass Shaft with Broadhead (Pack of 6)
Six glow-in-the-dark shafts, a spare accessory set, and a weight that hits hard.
Six arrows in one package is the practical reason this set lands so well — lose one to a stump and your night keeps going. The shafts run 34.8 inches long at 8mm outer diameter, and each one carries 104 grams. That weight is exactly why the point drives home on a big fish.
The glow-in-the-dark solid fiberglass shaft is the detail that changes how a night trip feels. A shaft that catches light lets you find a miss in dark water instead of writing it off. Nickel plated stainless steel points handle the slime and grit you will drag them through. This is a six-pack that also gives you a second full set of accessories, so a bent slide does not sideline the whole quiver.
Buyers praise the value most: six glow shafts plus a spare accessory set keep your cost per arrow low. Two things are worth knowing honestly. The arrows are roughly 104 g and that is heavier than the RUOERSI shafts at 100 g, so the flight arc is a little lazier and you will adjust your aim. And the nocks are fixed with glue, so a cracked nock means retiring that shaft. The broadhead and slide fit is a recurring discussion point on this set, and tightening points before each trip is the simple habit that prevents most of it.
Where it earns the spend: Six glow shafts plus a spare accessory set make this the most arrows for a full night out, with a 104 g shaft behind each shot.
Set your aim for it: Heavier shafts drop more over distance than the RUOERSI 100 g arrows, so plan for a slightly closer hold rather than a flat, long shot.
Reach for this when: you want a full quiver, night visibility, and spares in one box.
Look elsewhere if: you need to swap nocks — these are glue-fixed.
3. Muzzy Bowfishing Lighted Carbon Composite Archery Fish Arrow with Green X Nock Installed
A lit nock turns a dark-water miss into a visible, findable line.
If you shoot after sunset, this is the arrow that solves a specific problem: finding your shaft in black water. The Green X lighted nock, powered by Nockturnal, glows at the back end so you can track the whole flight and spot a miss before you start wading.
The shaft is a composite — 80% fiberglass and 20% carbon, per the manufacturer. That mix is meant to give you glass’s durability with some of carbon’s stiffness, and it comes cross-hole drilled for a slide. It is a single arrow, so treat it as the one you build your night setup around rather than the one you fill a quiver with.
One honest note: the internal spec sheet lists unusual figures on this listing, so judge it on what is clearly stated — the lighted nock and the fiberglass-carbon build. If you want raw numbers you can count on, this is a “buy for the lit nock” arrow, not a bulk pack.
The one feature that sells it: a factory-installed lighted nock on a cross-hole-drilled carbon-composite shaft — visibility at the moment you need it most.
Pick it when: night visibility is your priority and you want a lit nock without drilling or adding one yourself.
Skip the bulk plan: this is a single premium arrow, so a six-pack of glass shafts is the smarter fill for a full quiver.
4. OBTOUTDOOR 36 Inch Bowfishing Arrows 8mm Fishing Arrow (6 PCS)
A full 36 inches of glass shaft for shooters who need the extra reach.
36 inches is the standout here, sitting between the short 32 inchers and the long Muzzy at 37.5 inches. The glass fiber shaft is solid and does not float, so a miss sinks and stays where you can find it rather than drifting off with the current.
The details read like they were designed for wet, rushed hands. The nock tail is outsourced and tightly packaged so it releases clean without sticking. The metal spring sliding sleeve is built to thread a line fast and stay put. The tip is detachable, so you can swap accessories and back a fish off the barbs instead of losing the arrow.
The catch worth flagging: this is a longer shaft, so if your rest sits close to the grip, check your clearance before you buy. For a boat rig with room to spare, that extra length gives you a safer margin between the point and your hand.
The Build That Sold Us
- 36 inch glass fiber shaft for a longer forward reach than the 32 inch sets.
- Solid shaft that will not float off after a miss.
- Detachable barbed tip so you can retrieve easier.
- Metal spring sliding sleeve threads line quickly and holds.
The Clearance Check
- Longer shaft needs rest clearance — measure before buying.
- Heavier glass build than a hollow tube, so flight is slower.
- Six-arrow pack is heavier to carry on a long walk-in.
The right call for: boat shooters with rest clearance who want a longer reach and a retrievable tip.
Trim it if: your rest sits close to the grip and a 36 inch shaft will overhang.
5. AMEYXGS 3/6pcs Luminous Fiberglass Bowfishing Arrows with Broadheads and Safety Slides
A glowing shaft and a wide folding head built to slide through water.
Luminous shaft, yellow nocks, night bowfishing — this set is aimed squarely at the after-dark trip. The wide detachable head carries a foldable blade that cuts resistance as it enters the water, so the point is not fighting the surface on impact. A solid high-strength fiberglass shaft sits behind that head, and the stainless steel spring slide is described as wear-resistant and anti-corrosion, which matters on a wet boat.
The removable wide head is the practical part — you can replace it if it dulls or bends instead of scrapping the arrow. A six-arrow pack gives you enough shafts to keep shooting when one sails into the reeds.
The honest trade-off is that a foldable-blade head rewards careful handling; keep the blades tight and check them at the start of each trip. That small habit is what keeps the point cutting instead of wobbling.
Why night shooters grab it: a luminous shaft and yellow nock turn a dark-water shot into something you can actually track.
The maintenance habit: foldable blades need a quick tightness check before each outing.
Best matched to: night bowfishers who want a glowing shaft plus a replaceable wide head.
Think twice if: you want a fixed, no-maintenance head — folding blades need periodic tightening.
6. RUOERSI Bowfishing Arrows 34 inch with Safety Slides and Removeable Broadheads (2 Pack)
Two 34 inch shafts at 100 grams each — a light, precise pair.
At 100 g per shaft, these RUOERSI arrows are the lighter option next to the 104 g Tiger Archery shafts. Lighter means a flatter flight and a steadier aim for a shooter who does not need maximum mass. The 34 inch solid fiberglass shaft runs 8mm outer diameter, so it pairs with standard slides and rests.
The removable steel tips are the flexible part — swap them, sharpen them, replace them. The barbs are made so you rotate the arrow gently to back the fish off instead of cutting your line. Bright yellow nocks and slides are easy to spot on a dark bank, and the shafts work with a fishing reel.
Two arrows is a small kit, so plan for it as a light setup or a spare pair in the boat, not a full quiver. If you want to fill a quiver and still keep one set spare, the six-packs below make more sense.
The lighter-shaft advantage: 100 g per shaft against the 104 g Tiger shafts gives a flatter, quicker flight for precise shots.
Kit size reality: two arrows covers a short trip or a backup role, not a full night of shooting.
Good fit: a shooter who wants a light, precise pair of shafts with swappable tips.
Not the one if: you need a full quiver’s worth of arrows.
7. AMEYXGS 6/12pcs Archery Fiberglass Bowfishing Arrows with Broadheads and Safety Slides
A six-pack for casual outings, with stainless points and a slide already on.
This set is built around convenience: stainless steel tips with barbs designed for penetration and safety, a smooth fiberglass shaft, and a safety slide installed. Six arrows in the orange type covers a casual bowfishing excursion without a big layout. The tips can be removed and swapped, so a bent or dulled point is a replacement, not a lost arrow.
The smooth glass shaft is what owners tend to notice first — it is the thing that keeps flight consistent and accurate. On a six-arrow package, that consistency is what lets you trust the arrow and focus on the fish.
Honest note: the tips are the weak link in some packages, with reports of them working loose. Check and tighten the broadheads before each outing and that concern mostly goes away. For occasional trips rather than heavy competition, this is a sensible set.
What the buy gets you: six glass shafts with removable stainless points and slides installed — a casual-trip quiver in one box.
The honest weak point: tips can loosen; a pre-trip tightening habit solves most of it.
Suits you if: you want a six-arrow set for weekend bowfishing without a big spend.
Consider a different set if: you need heads that never work loose — the tips here need checking.
8. NIKA ARCHERY Bowfishing Arrows 32 Inch Solid Fiberglass Shaft for All Bows (3 Pack)
Short, solid, and built around a broadhead that holds more than 2.5 inches.
32 inches is the shortest shaft on this shelf, and that is the point — a compact arrow clears a short rest and keeps the weight forward where penetration happens. The 8mm outer diameter solid glass shaft comes with a safety slide and stopper installed, and three arrows come in the pack.
The broadhead is the real story. Two mechanical barbs open a holding area over 2.5 inches wide, and the tip releases by loosening it, so you back a fish off the arrow instead of cutting the line. The shafts fit compound bows, recurve bows, and long bows, which makes this a versatile three-pack for fish hunting and target practice.
One thing to plan for: the nocks are glued on, so treat them gently. On the plus side, that fixed nock gives you a very consistent release — check the glue joint when you first unbox, then you are set.
The build’s high point: a 2.5 inch holding barb on a short 32 inch solid shaft — ideal for close, heavy shots.
The one fixed limit: glued nocks cannot be swapped, so a cracked nock retires the shaft.
Best for: a short-rest bow and a shooter who wants a wide holding barb for close water.
Not for: anyone who needs to swap or repair nocks later.
9. GPP 32 Inch Bowfishing Arrows Solid Fiberglass Shaft with Broadheads and Safety Slides (6 PCS)
Six short shafts with wide barbs — the volume-shooting option.
Six arrows at 32 inches each gives you a full quiver for the price of a couple of singles elsewhere. The solid glass shaft runs an 8mm outer diameter with a safety slide and stopper, and the length keeps everything compact and forward-weighted for a close shot in the shallows.
The broadhead carries two mechanical barbs with over 2.5 inches of holding area, and it releases by loosening the tip so you can pull the arrow back out of the fish. The shafts fit compound, recurve, and long bows, which means a borrowed bow on a group trip works fine.
The fixed, glued nocks are the thing to accept going in. Check them on arrival, and if you plan to hit rocks or hard banks, treat this as the set you replace rather than repair. For volume shooting and introducing a friend to bowfishing, that trade is worth it.
Why a big quiver matters here: six 32 inch glass shafts means a lost arrow does not end the night.
The trade you accept: glued nocks and a budget build — this is a shoot-and-replace pack, not a long-term keeper.
Get this if: you want the most arrows for a casual or group trip and are fine replacing a snapped shaft.
Hold off if: you want one shaft you will repair and keep for years.
Understanding the Specs
Shaft Material: Solid Fiberglass vs. Hollow
A solid fiberglass shaft has no hollow core, so it sinks after a miss and resists splitting when it hits a rock. Hollow or composite shafts can float and travel, costing you the arrow. The trade-off is weight — solid glass arrays come in around 100 g to 104 g per shaft, which is why they fly slower but drive harder. If your goal is retrieval after a miss, solid glass is the safer pick.
Shaft Length and Rest Clearance
Bowfishing shafts run short, in the 32 inch to 37.5 inch range on this shelf. The length must clear your arrow rest without overhanging, or the shaft can catch on release. Measure the distance from your rest to your bow grip and add margin: a 32 inch shaft suits a compact rest, while a 36 inch to 37.5 inch shaft needs more forward room. Longer does not mean better — it means clearance.
Weight in Grams and What It Changes
Look for the shaft’s listed weight, usually 100 g to 104 g. A heavier shaft carries more energy into the water and through scales, but drops faster over distance. A lighter shaft like a 100 g arrow flies flatter and aims easier. There is no wrong choice, only a match to your shot distance and how hard your bow pulls. For close, heavy shots, heavier is helpful.
Safety Slides, Stoppers, and Glue-Fixed Nocks
The safety slide is the ring your line threads through, and the stopper keeps it from riding up the shaft. Together they keep a tethered arrow from snapping back toward you. Nocks are often glued on, which gives a consistent release but cannot be replaced. Check the slide and the glue joint before each trip, and tighten any broadhead that looks loose — those two habits prevent most field failures.
FAQ
What length bowfishing arrow do I need for my bow?
Are bowfishing arrows the same as regular target arrows?
Why do bowfishing arrows have glued nocks?
Will these arrows fit a compound bow and a recurve bow?
How do I get the arrow back out of a fish?
Do solid fiberglass arrows sink or float?
What is a safety slide and why does it matter?
Do I need glow-in-the-dark arrows for night bowfishing?
How often should I replace bowfishing arrows?
Is a lighter or heavier shaft better for a first bowfishing trip?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
The strongest all-around pick for the bowfishing arrows shelf is the Muzzy Classic Fiberglass Fish Arrow — a solid 37.5 inch shaft that arrives with the bottle slide and carp point already installed, so it is ready to shoot on the first night. The most popular set by far, though, is the TIGER ARCHERY 34inch pack, which puts six glow-in-the-dark shafts and a spare accessory set in one box for a full quiver’s worth of shooting. It carries 250+ owner ratings versus the Muzzy’s 268, which is why the six-arrow TIGER pack is the crowd favorite while the Muzzy sells as a single ready-to-shoot arrow. If you want a longer reach with a wide holding barb, the OBTOUTDOOR 36 Inch set is the one to reach for, and for a compact pair you can back a fish off with, the RUOERSI 34 inch two-pack fits a light kit.
How We Picked
We do not accept paid placement. Every pick is matched to a real buyer and a real use-case; we do not hands-on test units.
Sources & Methodology
Specifications: manufacturer listings and product documentation. Review insights: verified customer reviews, as of November 2026. Pricing: not shown on this page (it changes often); check the current price via the retailer link.
As an Amazon Associate, Gadgets Feed earns from qualifying purchases. This does not affect which products we feature.