7 Best Bug Spray Without DEET | 98-100% Effective Naturally

Get It On Amazon

The synthetic-active champion that matches DEET’s staying power without the odor.

If you want the longest-lasting DEET-free option, this is it. The Shubug uses a 20% Picaridin formula that is third-party tested to repel mosquitoes and ticks for up to 12 hours — that is a full day of hiking without a single reapply. Unlike essential oil sprays that fade after a few hours, this one stays active so you do not have to think about it. It also keeps no-see-ums (tiny biting flies), black flies, gnats, and chiggers away for up to 8 hours, so you get broad-spectrum protection in one spray. And because it is completely odorless and quick-drying, you will not walk around smelling like a bug spray.

The other big win is that it is safe for synthetic fabrics and plastics — you can spray it on your tent, backpack, or sunglasses without damaging them. That is a problem with high-concentration DEET but not with Picaridin. The package dimensions are 7.95 x 5.24 x 2.64 inches, so the 6 oz can is a bit taller than the Murphy’s Naturals bottle, but the 2-pack gives you a backup for the car or a second bag. Owners mention it “leaves zero stick or film” — so you forget it is on until the bugs stay away.

The main drawback is the price point, which sits at the premium end of the DEET-free range. But because a single application lasts a full day, you use less product per outing, which balances out the cost. Unlike the essential oil sprays below, which need reapplication every 5-6 hours, this one covers you from morning till dusk.

Get It On Amazon

The EPA-registered (government-reviewed) plant-based choice for a reliable 6-hour window.

Murphy’s Naturals is a go-to for anyone who wants a plant-derived active ingredient backed by the EPA. The formula uses 30% Oil of Lemon Eucalyptus (OLE), an EPA-registered active, and provides up to 6 hours of mosquito protection and up to 4 hours against ticks. That is narrower than the Shubug’s 12 hours, but for a short hike or a backyard barbecue, it is still plenty. The pump spray is non-greasy and leaves a fresh lemon scent — not a heavy citronella smell. At 6.83 x 4.86 x 1.3 inches per bottle, it is slimmer than the Shubug, so it sits flatter in a daypack.

It is family-friendly when used as directed, so it works for kids and adults (though you apply to hands first for the face to avoid eyes and mouth). The non-greasy formula also means it won’t stain your gear or clothing. Unlike the essential oil blends below that use geraniol or lemongrass, OLE is a single active compound with a more predictable, longer-lasting effect — but it is not recommended for children under three years old.

The biggest trade-off is the coverage duration: at 6 hours for mosquitoes and 4 hours for ticks, it falls short of the 12-hour claim on the Shubug. If you are on an all-day trek, you need to pack the bottle and reapply. And the 2-pack of 4 oz bottles gives you a total of 8 oz — less total volume than the Nantucket Spider’s single 8 oz bottle or the Lemongrass Farms twin pack.

Get It On Amazon

The essential oil blend that independent lab tests report as 98-100% effective.

Nantucket Spider’s Summer Camp spray is for families who want a fully natural, organic bug spray with data behind it. The formula uses seven certified organic essential oils — rosemary, geranium, cedarwood, peppermint, spearmint, lemongrass, and clove — and contains no citronella, which is a plus if you dislike that strong scent. Independent lab tests report it is 98-100% effective against mosquitoes and biting flies, an unusually specific claim for a natural spray. The sprayer is a fine mist trigger that covers skin evenly without drenching you. Customers note the light lemon oil scent is pleasant and that the spray is “non-sticky and non-oily” even with the essential oil content.

The bottle is 8 oz and measures 2 x 2 x 9 inches — a tall, slender cylinder that fits in a backpack side pocket. The company makes bottles from 100% post-consumer recycled plastic, and the ingredients besides the oils are only water and glycerin. For people with citrus oil sensitivities, one reviewer called it “the only spray that keeps me from a horrible rash.”

The catch is the coverage duration. Unlike the Picaridin-based Shubug that goes 12 hours, essential oil blends evaporate faster and need more frequent reapplication. You will likely need to spray every couple of hours to maintain that 98-100% effectiveness, especially if you sweat. Also, the fine mist trigger can spray unevenly if you do not hold it at the right angle — though the company has been praised for good customer service if there are sprayer issues.

Get It On Amazon

The travel-ready trio with a university study showing 90% repellency for gnats and black flies.

Medella Naturals’ travel pack gives you three bottles in one box — 2 oz, 4 oz, and 8 oz — so you can stash a small one in your pocket, keep a medium one in the car, and leave the big one at home. The active ingredient is lemongrass essential oil. The formula was tested at the University of Georgia’s Black Fly Rearing and Bioassay Laboratory: it repelled 90% of black flies and gnats up to 5.5 hours after application. That study makes this one of the few essential oil sprays with a published, third-party test result. The scent is lemongrass with a hint of vanilla, and it does not leave a sticky residue. Reviewers point out it works “well for daily woods use,” fitting the casual outdoor crowd.

The product dimensions are 5 x 2 x 8 inches, and the total weight is 1.06 pounds — about 23% lighter than the Lemongrass Farms twin pack (1.3 pounds). That matters if you carry the 8 oz bottle on a long walk. It is also safe for pets and kids when used as directed, and it is non-flammable and grass-safe. Unlike the Cutter OLE spray, which should not be used on children under three, Medella’s lemongrass formula is gentle enough for toddlers.

The main catch is that at 5.5 hours, the protection is shorter than the Shubug (12 hours) or Grandpa Gus’s (8 hours for ticks). You will need to reapply mid-afternoon if you are out all day. And while the 2 oz bottle is great for travel, the trigger sprayer on the big bottle can be stiff at first, as some buyers have noted.

Get It On Amazon

The plant-based spray that claims the longest tick protection among essential oil formulas.

Grandpa Gus’s puts ticks at the top of its hit list. This spray uses geraniol, lemongrass, and peppermint oils and claims to repel ticks for up to 8 hours and mosquitoes for up to 6 hours. Those are strong numbers for a purely plant-based formula — most essential oil blends fade faster. The brand recommends spraying directly onto pant legs and sleeves where ticks climb, a practical tip for anyone hiking through tall grass. The bottles are 4 oz each in a 2-pack, and the product dimensions are just 1.5 x 1.5 x 5.5 inches — the smallest profile in this list and significantly more compact than the Nantucket Spider’s 9-inch tall bottle. It weighs 10.58 ounces total for both bottles, about 32% heavier than the Nantucket Spider’s single 8 oz bottle.

The formula is non-greasy and non-irritating, and it is safe for kids when applied by an adult (but not for pets). It also carries a “dermatologist-tested” label, which adds a layer of trust for sensitive skin. The scent is noticeably herbal from the peppermint and lemongrass — stronger than the Medella’s vanilla-lemongrass, but not unpleasant.

The trade-off: it uses a simple nozzle rather than a fine mist, so you need to rub it in manually for full coverage. And the 8-hour tick claim is for ticks specifically — mosquito coverage drops to 6 hours, which is still good but not as high as the Shubug’s 12-hour universal claim. The small bottle also means you may run out faster if spraying clothing generously, compared to the larger 8 oz single bottles from Nantucket Spider or Medella.

Get It On Amazon

The entry-level twin pack that gives you the most liquid for your dollar.

Lemongrass Farms Trek is the most volume-focused option here. You get two 8 oz bottles for a total of 16 oz — more total product than any other single pack, double the Murphy’s Naturals 2-pack and 2 oz more than the Medella travel pack’s 14 oz. The formula uses peppermint, cedarwood, geraniol, and lemongrass essential oils in a water-based spray that dries fast with no greasy or sticky residue. It is a simple, no-fuss natural repellent for hiking, camping, and backyard use. The 1.3-pound weight is about 23% heavier than the Medella travel pack (1.06 pounds), but you get roughly 2 more ounces of liquid.

The sprayer is a standard trigger that covers skin evenly, and the formula is quick-drying so you can put on clothes right after applying. The company is American, family-owned, and says it supports critical pollinators with a portion of proceeds. The ingredients are straightforward: essential oils and water, no synthetic dyes or fragrances. Shoppers say it has a “clean lemon scent” that fades after application.

The downside is the lack of a tested coverage duration. Unlike the Nantucket Spider (98-100% lab-tested), Medella (90% at 5.5 hours), or Shubug (12 hours third-party tested), Lemongrass Farms does not provide a specific hour rating. You are basically guessing when to reapply. And the formula includes peppermint oil, which can irritate some people’s skin if applied too liberally — always test a small area first.

Get It On Amazon

The six-bottle bundle that delivers reliable OLE protection at a low per-bottle cost.

Cutter is a well-known brand, and this 6-pack of 4 oz pump sprays gives you Oil of Lemon Eucalyptus (OLE) protection at a very low per-bottle cost. The active ingredient is OLE derived from the leaves of the lemon eucalyptus tree, providing up to 6 hours of mosquito protection — the same as Murphy’s Naturals. The scent is a cool, fresh lemon eucalyptus, and the formula is designed to not feel oily or greasy. It is also labeled to repel mosquitoes that may carry West Nile virus, which adds a layer of confidence for areas where that is a concern.

That makes it the best value if you need to keep a can in every bag, the car, the garden shed, and the camping kit. The 4 oz pump is compact, and the item weight is 1.9 pounds for the whole 6-pack. The formula is aerosol-free, which some people prefer for even, directed spraying without the hiss of a pressurized can.

The catch: OLE is not recommended for children under three years old, and it does not last as long as Picaridin — 6 hours is half the 12-hour window of the Shubug. The 4 oz per bottle is also fairly small, so if you spray heavily on clothing, one bottle may only last a couple of outings. And as a brand-name product at a budget price, the trigger sprayer may feel slightly cheaper than the nozzles on the Nantucket Spider or Medella bottles.